Jack Pandl's Whitefish Bay Inn

RestaurantWhitefish Bay, WisconsinHours

Serving classic German and American dishes with outdoor seating in Whitefish Bay

About

Jack Pandl's Whitefish Bay Inn is a restaurant in Whitefish Bay. We offer an intimate space with outdoor seating for our classic German and American dishes, including Friday fish fries.

Lawrence Chen
2 months ago

An exquisite serendipity. I never anticipated returning to Milwaukee so soon. I revisited Riverside University High School to admire the sprawling ivy, and enjoyed a stunning seafood meal with impeccable service at Harbor House. Recently, because a friend was returning to China, and as someone who loves traveling by Greyhound, we naturally decided to take a trip together. Adulthood makes reunions difficult, and with the vast distance between us, this might well be our final farewell. Since my friend had visited nearly all of the lower 48 states except the Cheese State, I suggested exploring Wisconsin. ​In my student days, Whitefish Bay loomed as an unapproachable, affluent enclave. Two decades later, I realize the locals are incredibly welcoming, even to travelers dressed as casually as we were. ​We followed the chef’s recommendations. The duck liver soup was delightful, and the appetizer platter featured exceptional fried mushrooms and St. Louis-style ribs. The veal cutlet was tender, and the sweet, boneless whitefish fulfilled my wish of eating whitefish in Whitefish Bay. The service was so graciously attentive that, as an East Coaster, I can only envy this innate Midwestern warmth (you simply don't find this level of hospitality in PA). ​The classical soundtrack—Billy May, Hugo Winterhalter, Percy Faith—was elegantly joyful, a refreshing departure from the sorrowful ballads that plague many eateries. Having dined extensively during my years in Philadelphia, I can be a harsh critic: the shrimp sashimi was underwhelming, but hardly enough to cost them a star. The European melodies and German tavern ambiance evoked fond memories of my late landlady, Else Ankel, a Basel graduate who spent half a century studying botany in an 1800s Wisconsin house. ​I will undoubtedly return. Life is a sprawling composition—the turbulent Goldberg Variations meeting the lingering grace of Albinoni’s Adagio. It is a profound blessing to pause by Lake Michigan and savor the local catch. Harbor House remains unmatched for pure culinary execution, but this establishment takes the crown for conversation and atmosphere. (Carnevor’s steaks are excellent, but the environment is too chaotic and they forgot my wine.) ​Highly recommended. Bathed in a sunlit, floral 1960s Lana Del Rey aesthetic and swept by the lake breeze, it offers a moment of joy profoundly.

Seth M
3 months ago

I have been wanting to try Jack Pandl's Inn ever since moving to the greater Milwaukee area 3 years ago and finally remembered to check it out. The food was absolutely delicious, grounded in hearty German cuisine. Our waiter was incredibly helpful in guiding us through the menu. Portion sizes are very generous, and the outdoor patio is really quite lovely with a small fountain, a little slice of continental European style dining in Whitefish Bay. I highly recommend it.

P. Kahn
6 months ago

Jack Pandl's is a charming restaurant that we had a great experience at. Loved the vibe with the old German bier steins all over the place in what seems to be a converted house. The service we had was wonderful and the we all enjoyed our food - from fish fry to reuben to schnitzel. An authentic German weiss beer on tap was also a great addition. Loved the whole experience.

Luke
a year ago

German-themed neighborhood restaurant with good sized fairly diverse menu and drink selection. We had the Rueben and clubhouse sandwiches, the broccoli cheddar soup, and the chocolate mousse pie. All were very good. Complementary bread chips were a unique offering, great tasting, and refilled without having to request. Hostess and waitstaff were prompt, courteous, and knowledgeable. Water refill service was frequent. The restaurant itself is an older building with extensive decor, on the inside. The only negative is the bathrooms are very small and dated.

Review us

Frequently asked

  • What are your hours?

    Local time · GMT-5

    • MondayClosed
    • Tue – Thu11:30 AM – 9:00 PM
    • Friday11:30 AM – 10:00 PM
    • Saturday11:30 AM – 9:30 PM
    • Sunday10:30 AM – 8:30 PM

Is this yours?

Claim it to update photos, contact details and booking links, and reply to enquiries.

Claim this listing

Find this useful? Sharing helps local places most. How to share